Infinity Bay Spa & Beach Resort

“Infinity Bay Honest Review”

Just got back from an incredible stay at Infinity Bay, and while it was the best vacations ever! Here is our honest review. Good and Bad. **Pros:** -Room 1003-We rented a gorgeous beachfront one-bedroom on the second floor that totally exceeded our expectations. The decor was on point, and that… more

Just got back from an incredible stay at Infinity Bay, and while it was the best vacations ever! Here is our honest review. Good and Bad. **Pros:** -Room 1003-We rented a gorgeous beachfront one-bedroom on the second floor that totally exceeded our expectations. The decor was on point, and that huge hammock was much appreciated. The views and sunsets were breathtaking! - Awesome Location- The resort is perfectly situated. You can snorkel right from the beach, no excursions neededz - Timing-We went during Holy Week, which is usually a mad rush, but it wasn't overly crowded at all. - Shrimp Heaven- Don’t skip the shrimp at the palapa bar! The coconut and bang bang shrimp were absolutely delicious. **Cons:** - Check-In Woes-The check-in process was a bit of a hassle. We got there right on time but didn’t get into our room until 7 PM. It felt a little chaotic. - Menu Pricing- We went without the all-inclusive package and paid as we went, but the prices on the menu never matched what we were charged, especially for drinks. We were getting overcharged every time. Also, they include gratuity on the tab as well. It’s writing in Spanish, and we didn’t know, so we basically tipped twice as we also tipped 20% cash. Figured that out at the end of our trip. - Beer Mix-Ups-The beer taps were hit or miss. Four out of five times, we ended up with the wrong beer. - Slow Bar Service-The service at the palapa bar could definitely be faster. It took about 20 minutes on average to get a drink. - **Coffee Struggles**: The coffee pot in our room was a cold press, and let’s just say it didn’t make the best cup of coffee. That’s on us, though! Overall, despite a few hiccups, this trip was amazing, and we are already planning our return! If you’re looking for a beautiful getaway with killer views and tasty food, Infinity Bay is a solid choice!

less

“I would return”

I stayed at Infinity Bay in March of 2026 with a group of friends for a week. Overall I enjoyed my experience and would stay here again. Pros: - Beautiful coral reef in the ocean directly in front of the resort, just follow the ropes so you don't bump into the coral along the way. The hotel does … more

I stayed at Infinity Bay in March of 2026 with a group of friends for a week. Overall I enjoyed my experience and would stay here again. Pros: - Beautiful coral reef in the ocean directly in front of the resort, just follow the ropes so you don't bump into the coral along the way. The hotel does not provide free snorkel stuff but you can rent it from a vendor by the hotel for 15$ for like 3-4 hours. - Nice large rooms with comfortable beds -Extremely friendly staff -Decent gym for being a hotel gym and it has 24/7 access -The international buffet thats included in the all inclusive deal has limited options but all of the options were fresh and delicious. Way different than a typical all inclusive resort where I feel like i'm eating defrosted food at a hometown buffet. This felt like a home cooked meal made fresh by someone who loves you. Cons: -There is zero education about reef conservation. The only thing I saw was a little video playing amongst their slideshow of resort photos at the check in desk that showed coral reef being grown and transplanted. For how bleached and damaged the reef is I really wish they would take the time to have some educational materials or signs or anything. Even the gift shop sold non-reef safe sunscreen :( This really bothered me.... -They rent out beach chairs to cruise ship individuals so unless you find a chair at 9am you will not get a lounger at the pool or the beach for the rest of the day. -The all inclusive alcohol option was not worth it at all. It is not a full bar like most all inclusive resorts. You get a separate "all inclusive" drink menu that you can order from and the alcohol is all rail. At one point the server pulled out Mr Boston vodka which I haven't drank since I was a poor freshman in college! No one in our friend group could catch a buzz either. I'm not sure if the alcohol is watered down or if they just don't pour them as strong as in the states but if I return I will not be doing all inclusive alcohol again. I almost felt like the servers treated you worse when they saw your all inclusive band despite us still tipping very well. -Check in was way later than 3pm. They kept saying "the manager is checking to see if your room is ready" every 30 mins. We finally just went to the bar and came back hours later to our room being ready. I plan on coming back to roatan and I think i'd do infinity bay again. The biggest takeaway was to bring your own reef safe sunscreen, yell at the dummys who stand on the coral reef, and don't do the all inclusive alcohol! :)

less