Hilton Garden Inn Secaucus Meadowlands

“Wonderful Stay, Our Budget NYC Commute... Not So Much”

My wife and I were visiting our son in New York City and chose this hotel for several reasons, mainly to avoid Manhattan hotel prices and outrageous parking fees. We figured we’d found the perfect hack: stay just outside the city, save a bundle, and enjoy a quick, easy commute. First, let me say t… more

My wife and I were visiting our son in New York City and chose this hotel for several reasons, mainly to avoid Manhattan hotel prices and outrageous parking fees. We figured we’d found the perfect hack: stay just outside the city, save a bundle, and enjoy a quick, easy commute. First, let me say the hotel itself was excellent. The staff was friendly, the room was clean and comfortable, there was free parking (a beautiful phrase to any traveler’s ears), and complimentary coffee in the lobby to help you brace for the day ahead. No complaints at all about the property. Our grand plan revolved around the “easy access to public transportation.” On paper (or ChatGPT), it looked fantastic. The idea was to take a bus to the Port Authority Bus Terminal and then hop on the subway to Penn Station, where most of our activities were centered. Simple, right? Well… that’s where the adventure began. Getting to the bus stop involved trekking through snow, mud, and part of a Home Depot parking lot before reaching a stop planted at the corner of a very busy intersection. What looked straightforward on the map turned into a route that felt like a shortcut suggested by someone who had clearly never tried it themselves. Standing there, we quickly realized this was not the kind of area we’d be thrilled to navigate on foot late at night after a long day in the city. Financially, we had planned this with spreadsheet-level optimism: $4 each way on the bus $3 each for the subway $7 per person each way = $28 per day for the two of us Three days = $84 total Cue the record scratch. We pivoted to Plan B: taking the 9 minute train from Penn Station to Secaucus Junction via NJ Transit, then grabbing an Uber to the hotel because it was too far to walk. The train was about $5 each, and the Uber averaged $20–$25 plus tip. Our tidy $28 daily transportation cost suddenly ballooned to about $72 per day. Instead of $84 for the trip, we spent roughly $194 getting back and forth! So much for the “we’ll save so much money!” strategy. Bottom line: The hotel itself is a great value; clean, friendly, and comfortable with free parking. But if your plan is to rely on public transportation into Manhattan, be prepared for more logistics, more time (about an hour+ each way), and significantly more cost than you might expect. What looked easy online felt very different under real-world conditions. Would we stay here again? Yes! If we were visiting NYC? Nope! As budget travelers trying to outsmart New York City… let’s just say New York won that round.

less

“Comfortable and accessible”

The Hilton Garden Inn is nestled adjacent to several major highways which can be helpful to travelers, though careful attention should be paid when approaching the lot entrance since it is easy to miss unless one is careful. Check in was easy and the room was clean and spacious, which included a re… more

The Hilton Garden Inn is nestled adjacent to several major highways which can be helpful to travelers, though careful attention should be paid when approaching the lot entrance since it is easy to miss unless one is careful. Check in was easy and the room was clean and spacious, which included a refrigerator, microwave, and coffee maker. Despite sitting close to roadways, my room was quiet throughout the night. The hotel includes a pool and fitness center, though I did not see a business center for access to computer/printer. A $ breakfast is available with reasonable prices. An adjacent restaurant is available meals later in the day. Parking is easy with a large garage on the property. The property is not within walking distance to shops or attractions, so one will need ready access to a vehicle if the aim is to visit other than attend meetings within the hotel.

less